A Reality Show Where Islam Is The Biggest Star (NYT)

After reading the article, I did not really like it, as I thought it could have been better written.

At the beginning, I had no major problems with the article. This is because the article initially seemed to be cohorently written and easily understandable. The author, in my opinion, had also managed to keep the article interesting, by reporting interesting facts about the show and adding meaningful quotes from contestants or producers.

On closer analysis however, I noticed what I thought were several gaps, contradictions and unnecessary information within the article. A consequence of this was that the article fell short of meeting my expectation in convincing me how Islam could be the biggest star on Imam Muda.